Current State
Brent Crude
~$90/bbl
post-ceasefire retreat from $128 peak
Hormuz Strait
Partial Closure
~$2M/vessel fee · commercial traffic test
Ceasefire Status
Provisional
Islamabad talks ongoing · Apr 10
Supply Off Market
9.1 mbd
~20% of global supply · EIA April STEO
Q1
How long and how deep will the supply disruption be?

The Strait of Hormuz is in a provisional ceasefire — not fully closed, not fully open. Iran is permitting limited traffic under "Iranian management" at $2M/vessel. The 9.1 million barrels-per-day shut-in remains in effect.

Duration: Goldman models 21 more days of ~10% normal Hormuz flow even if the ceasefire holds. Morgan Stanley and Vitol both confirm normalization takes months even after political resolution — voyage lag (tanker repositioning from current anchorages) and persistent insurance premiums keep the physical market tight.

Infrastructure damage extends beyond Hormuz. Kazakhstan's CPC pipeline is sabotaged — confirmed 3–5 year repair timeline regardless of whether Hormuz reopens. Saudi Ras Tanura (drone strike), UAE Fujairah ADCOP (damaged), Qatar/Ras Laffan (evacuated) — full damage assessment still pending.

The key indicator: how many vessels actually pay the $2M fee vs. diverting to Cape of Good Hope. Commercial traffic at scale is the real stress test of the ceasefire's durability.

Key figure 9.1 mbd off the market ~20% of global supply · largest peacetime disruption on record
MEDIUM Ceasefire active but fragile; commercial traffic data will confirm or refute duration assumptions
Sources: EIA STEO April 2026 · Goldman Sachs · Morgan Stanley · Vitol · Dallas Fed · WTO AIS Tracker
Q2
How high can oil prices go?

Brent retreated from a $128 intraday peak (April 2) to the ~$90s following the April 7 ceasefire. Goldman revised Q2 forecasts to ~$90, reflecting the market's interpretation of the political development.

Three-scenario framework, now calibrated:

  • Scenario A — Ceasefire holds: $80–$90 · Most likely right now
  • Scenario B — Stalemate persists: $100–$120 · If Hormuz stays constrained 1+ month
  • Scenario C — Islamabad fails: $150–$180 · If Hormuz closes again and conflict resumes

Critical constraint: EIA's "conflict resolves by end of April → May recovery" assumption is structurally impossible even in the best case. The physical market lag of 45–60 days (confirmed by Morgan Stanley and Vitol) means the market stays tight through May–June regardless of political outcomes.

At ~$110/b, visible demand destruction is only ~1 mbd. To balance an 8–10 mbd deficit requires prices exceeding $150/b — the Morgan Stanley/JPMorgan scenario. The demand destruction ceiling exists but requires the worst case to activate.

Price ceiling $150–$180/bbl Scenario C: Islamabad fails, Hormuz closes again — Morgan Stanley / JPMorgan worst case
HIGH Multiple corroborating price targets; Goldman post-ceasefire revision confirms $90 range; $150+ tail scenario documented across banks
Sources: Goldman Sachs · Morgan Stanley · JPMorgan · EIA STEO · Dallas Fed · Vitol
Q3
What's the physical supply impact on Europe?

Europe is primarily exposed through oil price pass-through to refined products — not crude physical shortage at origin. But real physical shortages are already manifesting at retail level in some areas.

Gas storage: Germany, France, and the Netherlands are under 25% full as of March/April 2026 — thinner than the pre-winter starting position suggested. U.S. LNG export capacity is near maximum and cannot scale fast enough to offset the ~19% of global LNG that normally flows through Hormuz.

Physical manifestations observed:

  • Paris area (April 8): local gas station — no gasoline or diesel available. Only E85 (85% ethanol blend) in stock.
  • Italian airports: limiting jet fuel to 2,000–2,500 liters per A320 (vs. typical 18,000–26,000 liters).
  • German industrial gas scarcity warnings emerging.

Food price risk: The urea/fertilizer disruption pathway (Hormuz → ammonia/urea → fertilizer → food prices) has a 6–12 month lag. The food price impact won't be visible in current data but will show in Q4 2026–2027 harvest data. Most acute in fertilizer-importing Sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia.

Critical window Spring 2026 refilling season EU gas storage under 25% · if drawn further in Apr–May, the 2026–27 winter becomes acutely precarious
HIGH Field observation confirms physical shortage; multiple European sources converge; structural supply chain ripple effects documented
Sources: Reuters Europe Gas Scramble · ENTSOG · EIA STEO · UNCTAD · Field report (Ovidiu, Paris area, Apr 8 2026)
Real-World Observations
Field reports from the ground
Paris Area, France April 8, 2026
Local gas station found with only E85 (85% ethanol blend) available — no gasoline or diesel in stock. Physical shortages already materializing at retail level, earlier than "price inflation only" models predicted.
— Field report, oil-shock-monitor-kb
Cross-Institution Summary
Institution Supply View Price Forecast Europe View
EIA STEO 9.1 mbd, April resolution assumed $115/b Q2 peak, $76/b 2027 Price pass-through primary
Goldman Sachs 21 days at ~10% normal flow $90 Q2 base · $120 severe
Morgan Stanley Months to normalize $80–$90 base · $150+ tail Asian refineries hit first
JPMorgan $150+ worst case
Dallas Fed ~20% supply · first-ever full closure $98–$132 WTI scenarios Demand destruction above $100
Vitol (physical) Market pricing fast reopening Risk premium moderate Credit lines expanded $3B
UNCTAD 3.4B people in high-debt nations exposed Food price inflation pathway Developing world most acute
See all sources and data
Tweet digest · 28-day timeline · 73 tweets across 58 authors · Mar 03 – Apr 10, 2026
View Sources